Banner Image

Online vs In-Person Therapy: A Complete Comparison Guide

Compare costs, effectiveness, and benefits to choose the right format for your mental health needs

Browse

or detailed search

Introduction

Choosing between online and in-person therapy is one of the most important decisions you'll make in your mental health journey. Both options offer unique benefits and considerations, and understanding the differences can help you make an informed choice that best suits your needs, budget, and lifestyle.

Quick Comparison: Online vs In-Person Therapy

Factor Online Therapy In-Person Therapy
Average Cost (per session) $120 - $200 $150 - $250
Medicare Rebate Yes (same as in-person) Yes
Travel Time None 30-60 minutes
Geographic Limitations None - access specialists nationwide Limited to local providers
Scheduling Flexibility High - often evening/weekend availability Limited to office hours
Technical Requirements Stable internet, device with camera None

Cost Comparison: Online vs In-Person Therapy

Understanding the true cost of therapy involves more than just session fees. Let's break down all the expenses involved:

Session Costs

Online Therapy Costs:

  • Session fee: $120 - $200 per session
  • Medicare rebate: $98.95 (General Psychologist) or $145.25 (Clinical Psychologist)
  • Out-of-pocket cost: $23.35 - $103.35
  • Additional costs: None

In-Person Therapy Costs:

  • Session fee: $150 - $250 per session
  • Medicare rebate: $98.95 (General Psychologist) or $145.25 (Clinical Psychologist)
  • Out-of-pocket cost: $53.35 - $153.35
  • Additional costs: Travel, parking, time off work

Hidden Costs to Consider

Online Therapy Savings

  • No travel costs (fuel, public transport)
  • No parking fees
  • No time off work for travel
  • No childcare costs for travel time
  • Lower session fees overall

In-Person Additional Costs

  • Travel time (valued at $25-50/hour)
  • Parking fees ($5-15 per session)
  • Public transport costs
  • Time off work for travel
  • Higher session fees

Effectiveness: Online vs In-Person Therapy

Research Findings

Good news: Research consistently shows that online therapy is just as effective as in-person therapy for most mental health conditions, including depression, anxiety, PTSD, and relationship issues.

Conditions Where Both Formats Excel

  • Depression: Both formats show similar effectiveness rates (60-80% improvement)
  • Anxiety disorders: Comparable outcomes for GAD, social anxiety, and panic disorder
  • PTSD: Both formats effective, with online offering accessibility advantages
  • Relationship issues: Couples therapy works well in both formats
  • Stress management: Both formats equally effective

When In-Person May Be Preferred

  • Crisis situations: Immediate intervention and safety planning
  • Severe mental illness: When close monitoring is required
  • Children under 12: May benefit from in-person interaction
  • Group therapy: Often more effective in person
  • Physical health conditions: When physical symptoms need monitoring

Benefits Comparison

Benefits of Online Therapy

Convenience & Accessibility

  • No travel time or costs
  • Access to specialists nationwide
  • Flexible scheduling (evenings, weekends)
  • No need to take time off work
  • Comfort of your own environment
  • Easier to fit into busy schedules

Cost & Practical Benefits

  • Lower session costs
  • No parking or transport costs
  • Same Medicare rebates as in-person
  • Reduced childcare needs
  • No weather-related cancellations
  • Easy rescheduling options

Benefits of In-Person Therapy

Therapeutic Benefits

  • Full non-verbal communication
  • Immediate crisis intervention
  • Access to physical resources
  • Clear therapy environment
  • No technical distractions
  • More intimate therapeutic relationship

Practical Benefits

  • No internet connectivity issues
  • Structured appointment times
  • Physical separation from daily life
  • Access to clinic resources
  • Immediate support if needed
  • Traditional therapy experience

How to Choose: Decision Matrix

Choose Online Therapy If:

  • You have a busy schedule with limited free time
  • You live in a remote or rural area
  • You're comfortable with technology
  • Cost is a significant factor
  • You prefer the comfort of your own space
  • You need access to specialists not available locally
  • You have reliable internet and a private space

Choose In-Person Therapy If:

  • You prefer face-to-face interaction
  • You're in crisis or need immediate support
  • You have unreliable internet
  • You want clear boundaries between therapy and daily life
  • You need access to physical resources or materials
  • You're working with children under 12
  • You have severe mental health conditions requiring close monitoring

Medicare Rebates: Both Formats Equal

One of the most important points: Medicare rebates are identical for online and in-person therapy. This means:

  • Same rebate amounts regardless of format
  • Same 10 sessions per calendar year limit
  • Same Mental Health Treatment Plan requirements
  • Same GP referral process

Medicare Rebate Amounts (2024)

$145.25

per session with a Clinical Psychologist

$98.95

per session with a General Psychologist

Getting Started: Your Action Plan

  1. Assess your needs: Consider your schedule, budget, and preferences
  2. Check your internet: Ensure stable connection for online therapy
  3. Visit your GP: Get a Mental Health Treatment Plan
  4. Research providers: Look for therapists offering your preferred format
  5. Book a consultation: Many offer free initial consultations
  6. Try both formats: You can switch between formats if needed

Ready to Start Your Therapy Journey?

Whether you choose online or in-person therapy, we can help you find the right mental health professional for your needs and budget.

Find a Therapist Learn About Costs

Related Articles

Learn more about therapy options and mental health support:

Back to Complete Guide
Find a Therapist